"Your dog bit me. Why should I pay?" Liaoning Shenyang, the man comes home from the night shift, and the neighbor's dog comes out and bites him a few times! A man kicks his dog and goes home with a knife and stabs his dog! The neighbor takes the man to court and asks the man for compensation! The court: "Dog bites you, you can close the door and hide, and it's a good defense. Wang is a hard-working worker who comes home early every day. When he came to the door, he was taking the keys to the door, and the neighbor's dog suddenly drove his dog crazy and bit him a few times! The king ate the pain and kicked the dog away and then opened the door to the house! So he took the fruit knife from the table and went out and decided to teach the dog a lesson!
He had a knife in his hand, and Wang-tang had a temper! And the dog came out of his house and then came towards him! Wang is not afraid of it this time, he stabs the dog with a knife and throws all his breath into the dog!
Soon the dog will fall down and the king's hand will bleed! When Wang calmed down, the police came, and the neighbor Lee came out of the house and saw his dog lying on the floor with blood.
Wang was also taken to hospital on the same day, where he spent more than 18,000 over a period of time. Wang believed that his wounds were caused by the old Lee's dog, so he asked Li to pay for them!
But Li said, "My dog is a pure-blooded Labrador, and I bought it for 38,000, and this rescue cost 2,000, and you pay me back!"
You've got a dog, you've got a dog!
So Wang took Old Li to court, and Li brought a counter-claim.
In court, Wang insisted that old Li's dog was not tied up, so Li was not under the full duty of custody and as the dog's owner was liable for his bite! To this end, the Prince also provides a legal basis under which the owner of the dog is liable for any damage caused by a pet raised by another person. And Li countered that the dog was not taken to the street at the door of his house, and that Labrador was gentle and did not normally attack. That's why the dog bit him. Wang didn't think that Li would be able to bite so hard, he was so angry that he couldn't eat too much in the middle of the night and do nothing. There's not enough sleep time! But Li's words are crude, and if he does, it's Wang's fault!
Because the Civil Code exempts the owner of a dog from liability if the damage was caused by the victim ' s wilful or gross negligence! But the civil action is about evidence and who claims to prove it! There was no surveillance on either side of the house, and there was no proof of what happened at the time, so Li could not have accepted his views without proof! According to the judge, according to the police record, as well as the injuries sustained by Wang, and the circumstances at the scene, it can be concluded that it was his dog that bit him and that Li, as guardian of the dog, should be compensated. So the court ordered Li to pay for Wang's hospital expenses and $18,000 for his late work! Li said, "My dog bit Little King, I can pay, but Little King stabbed my dog to death and he's gonna pay for my dog." The dog bites him, he can hide at home, why stabs the dog with a knife, and he sees the dog like a dog!” The little king's words are stung because he did come home, and he was out of danger, but he went out and stabbed the dog again because he couldn't breathe!
Wang wanted to say I was an emergency, your dog bit me, I took the knife in self-defence, how can I promise he won't bite me again when he leaves?
In accordance with the Civil Code, emergency avoidance measures are inappropriate or exceed the necessary limits, and the emergency avoidance person bears appropriate civil liability.
So the judge considered that since Wang had already opened the door to the house, he could have closed the door and gone into hiding to report the incident.
In conclusion, the court held that the owner of the dog, Li, did not take 60% of the responsibility for the dog's death, and the King took 40% of the responsibility for revenge, even though the King paid 38,000 dollars for the dog's loss and 40% for treatment of 2,000, so the King paid Li 16,000!
Legally, Li's dog bites the king, but the king kills the dog, and his anger is liable!
In this case, some netizens said that Wang was strong, so he didn't get bit by a dog. Is it the dog that bites him to death? Even killing a dog is a defence, and from another point of view, it's for good cause. After all, if the dog doesn't die, he might bite somebody else!
There are also netizens who say that dogs, as pets, are the owner's private property, and that since they have gone home to close the door, far from the dog, they can pay back the owner's theory, including through the estate, and take revenge for killing the dog, which is the free disposal of other people's property!
So, what do you think about that?